Friday, December 20, 2019

Supreme Court Cases

Alyssa Cruz 
Supreme Court Cases 

Benjamin Disraeli once said, “Justice is truth in action.” Meaning, in order to seek justice, you would have to work hard for it. Justice, is a word used often to display an accomplishment within the court system. Due to effort and determination that the people used to fight for their rights, led to their belief in reaching for their goal for justice to be served. In these Supreme Court Cases, including, Kent Vs. U.S., Veronia School District Vs. Acton, Tinker Vs. Des Moines, and New Jersey Vs. T.L.O, are examples of times people fought for justice, in order for justice to be rightfully served.

For this Supreme Court Case, of Kent Vs. U.S., this issue involved a teenager (Kent) being tried for an adult. Within this case, the decision that was made was 5-4 for Kent. Chief Justice Abe Fortas in charge of this case was appointed by President Lyndon B. Johnson. Based on the work of this case, Kent was arrested at the age of 16 under the counts of housebreaking, robbery, rape, and even past incidents. He was first tried as a juvenile until the juvenile court waived its jurisdiction. Meaning, that the jury made their decision of making Kent to become tried as an adult. ("Kent v. United States." Oyez, 15 Oct. 2017, www.oyez.org/cases/1965/104.) Due to this conviction, Kent ended up being sent to prison for 30-90 years. The majority opinion was by Chief Justice Abe Fortas and there was a dissention based on Kent’s age. Some may feel that he shouldn’t be tried as an adult based off of his age. But the truth of the matter is that justice being served in this case turned out to be like a double-edged sword.

This is another Supreme Court Case that displayed a way of justice being served, Vernonia School District Vs. Acton. In this case, the issue is dealing with the Student Athlete Drug Policy. The vote upon this case was 6-3 for Vernonia School District. Chief Justice Antonin Scalia who was appointed by President Ronald Reagan was in charge when it came to this case. According to this case, it was concerning student athletes of the abuse of drug use and how school officials are violating their privacy. The school officials enforced the Student Athlete Drug Policy by conducting a random urinalysis drug testing for students. ("Vernonia School District 47J v. Acton." Oyez, 15 Oct. 2017, www.oyez.org/cases/1994/94-590.) This was clearly a violation of the 4th Amendment which led to many parents to bring this case to the Supreme court. The majority opinion was by the Chief Justice Antonin Scalia for Vernonia School District was because of how school officials have a right upon the safety of their students. In this case, justice was being served in order to protect the lives of the student athletes and to make sure they are safe to make right decisions.

Based on this next Supreme Court Case, Tinker Vs. Des Moines, revealed that everyone, no matter what age, is truly and naturally equal. This issue upon this case involved the violation of the First Amendment. The vote was 7-2 decision for Tinker. The Chief Justice Abe Fortas who was appointed by President Lyndon B. Johnson. 16- year old, Christopher Eckhardt and Mary Tinker were planning a public showing of their support upon the truce dealing with the Vietnam War. ("Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District." Oyez, 15 Oct. 2017, www.oyez.org/cases/1968/21.) By wearing black armbands, it was their way of expressing their opinion on a cultural event. Their school, however, had a different opinion of expression. This eventually led to the Supreme Court because of the fact that their first amendment was violated. The majority opinion by Chief Justice Abe Fortas for Tinker because they understood that the students were being disrespected by not having their freedom of expression. This was an example of justice being served through action because these students didn’t give up and fought hard for earning their respect. Working hard and determination made these students not only win the case, but create a statement.

The Supreme Court Case of New Jersey Vs. T.L.O, contained the concept regarding the 4th Amendment. The vote upon this case was a 6-3 decision through the Chief Justice Byron R. White who was appointed by President John F. Kennedy. Within the case, school officials searched through TLO’s purse due to the suspicion of having cigarettes. During the search, the authorities found drugs and a list of names. TLO claimed to search to be illegal however the school officials stated that the search was under a reasonable suspicion. ("New Jersey v. T.L.O." Oyez, 15 Oct. 2017, www.oyez.org/cases/1983/83-712.) The majority opinion would be for New Jersey because of the fact that due to the circumstances of the situation, the search was nothing but reasonable. This would be another example of justice being served because it pointed out the message of how drugs negatively impact the lives of the students and that teachers should be more aware.



Based on these Supreme Court Cases, Kent Vs. U.S., Vernonia School District Vs. Acton, Tinker Vs. Des Moines, and New Jersey Vs. T.L.O, have the same message of justice and action. Upon the first case of Kent Vs. U.S., had an impact on this student because this is evident on how kids could possibly be in trial as an adult. In the second discussed case, of Vernonia School District Vs. Acton, explained how student athletes were being impacted by the new school drug policy. Furthermore, in the third case, of Tinker Vs. Des Moines, dealt with the students fighting for their right of the First Amendment (having free speech), when it comes to what they wear. According to the Supreme Court’s decision, it became known that anyone could fight for their right and earn their justice by working hard and battling through obstacles. Finally, in the fourth case of New Jersey Vs. T.L.O, involved with the reasonable search of a student’s purse due to circumstances of the event. The overall message of these Supreme Court Cases combined would be to fight for justice in order to reach your goal.

Bibliography 
“Kent v. United States." Oyez, 15 Oct. 2017, www.oyez.org/cases/1965/104.”
"New Jersey v. T.L.O." Oyez, 15 Oct. 2017, www.oyez.org/cases/1983/83-712.”
"Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Community School District." Oyez, 15 Oct. 2017, www.oyez.org/cases/1968/21.
"Vernonia School District 47J v. Acton." Oyez, 15 Oct. 2017, www.oyez.org/cases/1994/94-590.”

No comments:

Post a Comment

Final Examination: Final Course Reflection

       From my previous experience in ENG101 to ENG201, I'm proud to say I improved a lot on research, presentation skills, public speak...