Alyssa Cruz, Evelyn Mejia, Cheyenne Ramos, David Wallace
Professor Matyakubova
ENG201: Composition 2: Disciplinary Investigations Exploring Writing (Section 06)
3 April 2020
Group Argumentative Essay: A Deadly Device
The world now is more connected than ever before. People are able to interact and share their lives with one another without talking to one another. This is due to the rise of social media in today’s society. People of all ages use social media as an outlet to post pictures of their day to day lives and connect with millions of people around the world. However, is it always a good thing when people interact and share their lives on social media? While the juxtaposition may argue that social media has a positive influence on society and the interaction that we have online, there is evidence to reveal that this is not the case. The rise of social media has had a negative influence on society due to the negative impacts that it can have on an individual’s life and self-esteem.
David Wallace- Ethos
Mane experts have conducted studies in order to see the negative effects that social media can have on someone. The studies conducted usually adolescence into their studies because it is the age group that is most likely to use social media consistently. In the article Is Social media bad for mental health and wellbeing? Exploring the perspectives of adolescents. The authors conduct an experiment in order to see how adolescents feel after spending time on social media. According to Michelle O'Reilly, the lead author, “six focus groups took over three months with 54 adolescence”(O'Reilly). This shows that the author did not have the biggest sample size but still had a large number of people. After the study was conducted the author was able to conclude that “it was viewed as a platform for cyberbullying”(O'Reilly). If social media is viewed as a way for people to be exposed to bullying is it really a positive component of society? The simple answer is no cyberbullying can lead to individuals having a feeling that causes them to hurt themselves or have very low self-esteem. According to an article called Negative Effects of Cyberbullying and Social Media Use among Young Adolescents by Auria Johnson “Negative Effects of cyberbullying on adolescents include depression, anxiety, self-esteem, absences from school, and increases in suicidal ideation among them”(Johnson). This quote shows how detrimental it is to someone who has been bullied online. If students are being absent from school that is more of a reason to help find a solution to the negativity that is brought by social media. By not going to school and isolating themselves people exposed to cyberbullying are bound to have a lot of negative thoughts about themselves which can lead to tragedy. These studies and observations are reasons that the issues that social media has been portrayed as negative.
Alyssa Cruz- Logos
The gift of technology is good and yet gives access to predators against young teenagers. Young adolescents are a target when it comes to the harsh reality of social media. Male and female teenagers have different perspectives and views about social media as a whole. Many female students would talk about how adult males would approach young girls on the internet asking for graphic pictures. Based on the video, Real Life Teens. Dangers of Social Media, “51% of girls are pressured to send nudity and sexting. And there are only 18% of males who are pressured to send inappropriate pictures.” (Flats) Females are at high risk of social media dangers because of the way they expose themselves to the world and to others. To young girls starting middle school or high school feel as though it is their way of developing a reputation.. With that being said, many young adolescents try to “not be a statistic” and their representation through text does not show their true character. Trying to not become a statistic sets the mindset for a lot of teenagers to not understand. Yet, there are many people relating to the situation of social media being a danger to their lives. According to the chart below, shows a percentage of users who use social media and charted the way they feel when using these social medias. The red dots represent the sad users and the blue dots represent the happy users. In the chart, you could see the more amount of time spent on social media the more upsetting the users get. From the founding president of Facebook, Sean Parker stated how the usage of Facebook is “exploiting a vulnerability in human psychology” (The Economist). Many people deal with mental health while using social media. For young teenage girls, creating their reputation in middle school and/or high school could easily be against their favor when something in social media spreads. Cyber Bullying is common around this specific demographic because of the easy access given to everyone. Based on the Oxford English Dictionary, the word cyberbullying, “is the use of information technology to bully a person by sending or posting text or images of an intimidating or threatening nature” (“cyber-”) . Cyber Bullying not only affects someone’s status but also their mental health. Affecting a young adolescent’s mental health leaves a heavy impact on them as they start going to school and living their everyday life. According to the graph, Facts on Cyber Bullying, the highest percentage of people on Facebook is 60%. (Statistics) There are also other percentages like 45% of people who committed suicide due to cyberbullying. Facebook is one of the biggest forms of social media and is actually one of the first social media to blow up to a generation. Young teen girls are taken advantage of through their vulnerability and thinking that they are in love with a stranger. Throughout the news, in particular, this segment of The Dangers of Facebook is talking about sexual harassment in social media. The video starts off talking about a 17-year-old girl who was raped and murdered because she met up with a guy online. Explaining how she’s alone and overweight makes her a target for sexual predators to take advantage. Researchers state how there are “39% of kids who are groomed by adult males to meet up and engage in sexual activities”. (Dangers) There are more stories just like her that eventually lead to suicide. Others face jail time and a criminal record. For instance, a male student got arrested for pretending to be a girl on the internet to get other male students their nude pictures to blackmail them into having sexual intercourse. Another case was also brought up about a lady who works at a daycare who sexually abused the kids and sent it to two people on Facebook. People say how kids and teenagers should always be aware of the dangers of social media yet the blame is not towards the social media platform itself, it’s the victim.
Cheyenne Ramos- Pathos
While many see social media as the easiest way to connect with others, it brings so many issues to our society. Everyone is constantly on social media, one of the most popular applications being Instagram. Instagram allows people to share photos on their profile of whatever they want and whenever they want. There are many celebrities that are seen as role models for all of their followers, and social media is a great way for them to engage with each other. However, having all of these celebrities who fit the societal standard of “beautiful”, such as Kim Kardashian and Kylie Jenner, can also often affect their followers and how they think of themselves. Cosmetic surgery is very popular today, changing features we don't like about our body or face and making us feel more confident. But what happens when clients are coming in for consultations, asking to change their appearance to look like a celebrity they idolize. Jia Tolentino, a writer for The New Yorker, wrote an article entitled The Age of Instagram Face. In her article, she discusses her experiences in consultations with some of the most well known cosmetic surgeons in Beverly Hills, California. She found herself wanting to fix aspects of her face when using a snapchat filter that got rid of blemishes, wrinkles, and other things that are not exactly desired in today’s society. When asking Jason Diamond, a cosmetic surgeon known for his work on celebrities, what he thought about clients trying to look like celebrities due to a photo they saw online, he responded,“I’d say that thirty percent of people come in with a photo of Kim, or someone like Kim—there’s a handful of people, but she’s at the very top of the list, and understandably so. It’s one of the biggest challenges I have, educating the person about whether it’s reasonable to try to move along that path toward Kim’s face, or toward whoever…” (Tolentino) Due to social media giving an outline of what is “beautiful,” people now are getting cosmetic surgery to fit that standard. Everyone’s self esteem and self confidence levels are getting lower and lower. Seeing these “picture-perfect” versions of someone being constantly presented to them makes them look at the differences between themselves and the celebrity.
Constantly being on your phone stimulates your mind, causing sleep deprivation. Many people fall asleep by watching Netflix on their phones or even videos on Youtube. In the article, “#Sleepyteens: Social media use in adolescence is associated with poor sleep quality, anxiety, depression and low self-esteem,” a survey was conducted to find the correlation between social media use and poor sleep quality, anxiety, depression, and low self-esteem. The results found that all of these may be connected to one another. The feedback from social media may increase anxiety levels while simultaneously lowering your self-esteem levels.(Woods) This study was performed on teenagers between the ages of eleven and seventeen. Children, constantly on their phones until they fall asleep with their phone screen pressed against their cheek, going to school the next day barely able to keep their eyes open. All of the vibrations and rings coming out of their device, waking them up in between their sleep, making them want to reach for their phones and see if someone liked their post, or if they got a new follower on Instagram. Social media has made our society crave for acceptance from others and has everyone hooked that our whole take on day to day life is being affected. A like on a social media post should not be affecting our mental health.
Evelyn Mejia- Counterclaim
Social media is a platform that allows for communication, people meet new people and maintain relationships with others via this form of networking. Social media is harmful because you don't know who you are talking to via a screen and it's dangerous because it causes depression and anxiety. Alternatively, some say that social media is a platform that creates the possibility for people to interact and help build their self esteem. According to “Social media, Social Capital and Adolescents living in State Care: A Multi-Perspective and Multi-Method Qualitative Study, people that aren't in a steady home need a form of support from isolation for their mental well being and have achieved this from using social media because they maintain relationships through this form of communication when they move to a new home. Although social media can seem beneficial in that aspect it is unlikely to maintain its healthy effects to the user because social media has been linked to, being a source of addiction that leads to depression.
Alyssa Cruz - Conclusion (Kairos)
Due to the rise of social media, it brings negative impacts on young individuals, such as self-esteem, depression, and cyberbullying. Male and female students have different perspectives when dealing with social media. The majority of women were either sexually harassed or bullied on a social media platform. In modern-day society, women and men are still getting judged by their body image, physical appearance, relationship status, even their sexuality. Social media gives access to many people to communicate and to create their self-expression however social media causes more harm than good. The harsh reality of social media led many young adolescents into suicide and put criminals where they belong. To the younger generation, it is important to know that there are other ways to communicate. Being face to face with the person and giving them your attention would lead to a healthy relationship. Young people should be able to learn about their usage of social media at an early age. Through the influence of peers, media, education, and family, students should be given an opportunity to learn about the dangers coming from a deadly device.
No comments:
Post a Comment