ENG201: Alyssa Cruz’s Voice Over Opinion
VOICE OVER OPINION
RESEARCH PAPER DRAFT #1
WRITTEN BY: ALYSSA CRUZ
JOHN JAY COLLEGE OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE
ENG201: DISCIPLINARY INVESTIGATIONS EXPLORING WRITING ACROSS THE DISCIPLINES
SECTION 06
PROFESSOR MATYAKUBOVA
APRIL 24 2020
ENG201: Research Paper Draft #1- Voice Over Opinion
Pallas Gutierrez once said, “If your First Amendment rights allow you to say heinous things about minorities, my First Amendment rights allow me to say that you are an uncaring person” (Gutierrez 2019). Due to the First Amendment, individuals are allowed to express their opinion on topics such as sexual orientation, their taste in entertainment, religion, race, culture, and so much more. The First Amendment does allow people to say how they feel, however, the usage of exercising to do so can also be misrepresented. Giving access and the right resources to contribute to the idea of free speech could eventually lead to hate speech. Based on the Oxford English Dictionary, Hate Speech is a term used for “inciting hatred or intolerance especially towards a particular social group on the basis of ethnicity, religious beliefs, sexuality, etc” (“hate,n”). Hate Speech has been shown throughout the course of time including modern-day society. To what extent, does hate speech violate the first amendment which is the right of free speech? Social Media platforms, such as Twitter, Instagram, Youtube, and Facebook, give access to people to conduct hate speech which violates the First Amendment and increases sexism, racial profiling and cyberbullying.
As a nation, people are taught to know what their human rights are. In History or Government class, students are learning about the Constitution and the first thing students will see is the First Amendment. Based on the Constitution of the United States of America, the First Amendment is stated in the following:
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people peaceably to assemble and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. (Constitute 1789)
The First Amendment gave freedom of speech, petition, assembly, and religion to all. People follow this Amendment by expressing themselves and identifying themselves in multiple ways. People would go to church, protest about gun laws, make town hall meetings, and so much more. Younger generations express themselves through their environment, friend groups, clothing, religion, and they eventually find a better way to express themselves through the internet. Social media platforms such as Twitter, Facebook, Instagram all have a different purpose yet all have commonality for instance, memes, likes, and hate comments.
I was interviewing my 14-year old cousin, Caitlin Ortiz-Luis through facetiming about hate speech and feminism in social media. My cousin, Caitlin is in 9th Grade, a freshman in a Catholic High School. I asked her if she has ever heard of the term “Hate Speech” before and she told me she had not. Through the explanation of my research paper and the findings I have discovered, Caitlin understood and remembered how celebrities and social media influencers get hate comments. She is usually on social media everyday, usually on apps like Snapchat and Tik Tok. Being on the basketball team, she dealt with hate speech when it came to her brother who would throw insults at her on how she sucks at basketball because she is a girl. She has been on the basketball team since she was 8, which are the years from 2013-2020. Even though the words are coming from her brother, it still impacts her while playing the game of basketball.
Caitlin told me, “With people with a low self-esteem, words can destroy you.”
I asked my cousin, “How do you exercise your First Amendment right?”
She replied with a laugh, “By using a treadmill and doing squats.”
All jokes aside, she mentioned how she goes to church and prays in public for example, praying in restaurants and school. The more you think about certain things, the more you start to overthink. Opinions have no right or wrong answer except when people make judgements and internally think of what you said is ridiculous. Given the easier access on the Internet, it makes everything easier and a way for predators and other dangerous people to manipulate, catfish, and purchase deadly weapons.
Through the form of hate speech, people could turn something completely innocent into something dangerous. I also asked her what type of ways she forms an opinion. Caitlin replied by saying opinions about choice of tv shows, and will rant to her friends. She will also keep it to herself knowing it would hurt someone. Caitlin goes to a dominant white school and the least population is the black community. She told me that students will make racial slurs towards the one black student in her class. By saying the “N” word and comparing the black student to Frozone in The Incredibles or any other known black person in the film industry, she knew that it is wrong therefore it is hate speech. From this peer-review journal, Free Speech and Slurs: Rights vs. Respect, it states, “Based upon numerous court opinions that have maintained the protection of free speech, especially in public, the use of slurs in public would be considered a form of protected speech in most cases” (Travis 2017) The use of slurs especially words towards specific populations should be regulated under the form of hate speech. Allowing younger generations and adolescents to use slur words, like the “N” word would give the dominant group permission to use that word despite knowing the word’s history. I hear teenagers and adults say the “N” word and rap the “N” word in music. There should be a line into normalizing slur language in society so that specific groups of people would not cross a boundary where it becomes hate speech.
Throughout our history, the First Amendment has shaped society and human interactions. The ability to express ourselves regardless of judgment should not matter because indefinitely you are under the law and have a right to voice your opinion. In time, there are many court cases about the First Amendment which deals with what people believe in. The cases that impacted the way society uses the First Amendment would be Tinker vs. Des Moines and Virginia Vs. Black. Back at my Freshman Year of High School, I learned about the case of Tinker vs. Des Moines. I was inspired by the way these students fought hard for their right to be heard. In this case, Mary Beth Tinker and a group of students wanted to wear black armbands to represent the truce in the Vietnam War. Later on within the school year, the Des Moines School made a policy towards those who would wear armbands were to remove it right away, and if there was a refusal the student would either be suspended or sent home. After suing the Des Moines School, Tinker made her way up to the Supreme Court and got the ruling in her favor. Based on the case, the Supreme Court Justices stated, “The school officials must be able to prove that the conduct in question would ‘materially and substantially interfere’ with the operation of the school” (Tinker). The use of the First Amendment did not incite violence and did not conduct a form of hate speech. However, there are cases in which hate speech and specific hate groups hide under the First Amendment by saying that inciting violence is a way of free speech. The case of Virginia vs Black is about when a group, also known as, the Ku Klux Klan burns a cross in a location with a majority of the black population. According to the peer-reviewed journal, Cross Burning, Hate Speech, and Free Speech in America, the journal states, “Burning a cross is a reminder that some Americans yet believe in white supremacy, racial persecution, or ethnic hatred. Burning a cross is a ‘symbol of hate,’ as the Supreme Court recently observed. Cross burning is a hate speech” (Edward). Attacking one’s religion crosses many lines to me personally. Seeing this action in movies and reading about it in history books disturbs me. The white supremacy is still ongoing today in regards to hate groups forming on the internet. Based on the audio visual called, Hate and the Internet: Web Sites and the Issue of Free Speech, a former KKK member, Don Black created a website called Stormfront. (Hate) This website of Stormfront gives access to many individuals to express their opinion on white supremacy and to promote a specific standpoint about politics. This interactive way of communicating with people triggers a global phenomenon of hate and inciting violence. In modern day society, 83 year old Floyd Abrams is an American attorney who has studied the First Amendment. Throughout his experience, he dealt with cases for example, “Varity Corporation v Howe, Herbert v. Lando, and the Nixon v. Warner Communications, Inc case”. (Floyd). The Nixon v. Warner Communications, Inc case is the most significant due to the fact that students learn about this case in school to know how those with authority should have limitations to exercise their freedom of speech. There are other cases just like this all over the world and throughout our history. However, cases like Virgina vs Black, are more of hateful speech than it is justifiable yet these court cases still hold a big contribution to what the Constitution is today.
Society can get very critical and judgmental which makes a lot of young women follow the norms. In social media platforms such as Instagram, Facebook, and Twitter, females are at a higher risk to be in forms of virtual abuse. From body shaming, gossip, and the idea of feminism, women have it much harder for them to express their own opinion. Based on the youtube video, Here’s What Online Harassment Looks Like, Ahmed Shihab-Eldin uncovers three stories of women who have dealt with online abuse. He also reveals many data by saying, “Young women are especially likely to experience sexualized abuse. ⅕ of women between ages 18 to 29 report online sexual harassment” (AJ+) . He also discovers solutions for instance, in the social media platform of Facebook, they depend on the community to flag any inappropriate/misleading pictures and information. Through these words of hate targeted at women, it eventually leads to cyber mobs, cyberbullying, and canceled culture. In our society, it gets more and more addicted to being on the internet. Although the internet does have its benefits, there are also downfalls in the world wide web. Cyber mobs are created under one commonality which are words of hate towards someone. Cyber mobs could cause major upbringings and are most likely to cause harm and destruction towards a group of people, even the community. Cyberbullying has become a major hot topic for so long as the internet still continues to grow and develop. Cyberbullying has been shown through forms of entertainment, like shows 13 reasons why, “Law & Order”, “Cyberbully”, etc. Cyberbullying has also been acknowledged in school assemblies and at home where parents are telling their children to be careful online. Based on the graph on the right, the graph shows how students and children develop social anxiety, depression, and harassment online. 34% of students have been cyberbullied (MustTech). Parents at home should be able to teach their kids how to be careful on the internet especially when it involves a stranger asking for explicit pictures, what they say for example use of slur words, and developing actions that make them go into the wrong direction. Through research, I discovered the survey about the high risk of teenagers who use social media is at a high risk of Cyberbullying. Based on the graph to the left, “The risk of getting depression from online interaction is 3.5% greater on Cyberbullying in social platforms for example Facebook.” (Pulse). Due to hate speech and the depression rates, coming from that, teenagers, children, and adults are at high risk for suicide. When it comes to the ideas of Cyberbullying, different platforms for example, Twitter has developed another way of cyberbullying called “Cancel Culture”. Cancel Culture aligns itself with cancelling someone about what they said or did on a social media platform. This mainly goes towards those who have influence on the internet and it shows how easily people could easily destroy one’s career by not supporting them anymore. I have seen the hashtag “#{someone’s name}isoverparty” trending on Twitter ever so often. The hashtag analyzes what someone has said or did and turns it into a form of hate speech. Based on the Newspaper Article, A Case For Cancel Culture, “A lack of consequences for celebrities and influencers often means they don’t learn about the extent of the harm they inflict, and sexism and racism ignored and unchecked only grows” (A case). This newspaper article analyzes how canceling someone could be a positive thing by making those in authority be responsible for their actions however, canceling someone could also lead to depression, misleading information, and a high potential to ruin one’s livelihood. Those who have high influence on society and a sense of authority should learn the circumstances that they are in when using the internet. Knowing the high risk of influencing younger generations and to use their platform for a greater good, would have a positive impact than using their platform to promote hate and incite violence.
Speaking of celebrities and social media influencers, they also have experienced online abuse by expressing their own opinion on a specific topic. Men influence the way women think/say about certain topics. Their physical strength overpowers women and allows men to have dominant control. Females have a fear of expressing their opinion online knowing the consequences which are death threats, rape threats, and bomb threats. 37 year old Anita Sarkessian is a femninst who speaks out about the issue of sexism and misogyny in video games. She is the host and creator of “Feminist Frequency” where she analyzes video games and notices how the females are usually the ones who are “Damsel in Distress” or primarily a sexual object. Playing video games growing up, I have always seen video games that make women more appealing and sexualized compared to the male characters. In the game known as “Injustice”, the DC characters like Catwoman, Harley Quinn, and Wonder Woman show more skin compared to the characters of Superman, Batman, and Flash. Men have more attention for a skill that they do meanwhile women have attention for their physical appearances. This analyzation caused a major outbreak in the subculture of video gamers which became the #gamergate. Gamergate is a way for male video game players to call feminists who describe their passion as misogynistic and sexist. Based on the video, What It Feels Like to Be a Gamergate Target, they discovered, “Someone even created a grotesque game where players can beat and punch a picture of Anita Sarkessian but the virtual harassment turned very real when her online attackers published her social security number and her address” (ABS news). To be in Anita’s shoes, is absolutely terrifying and yet she isn’t the only one going through similar threats. A game developer, Brianna Wu along with other female video game players/developers deal with death threats and sexual harassment. There was an episode in Law & Order: SUV, where a female like Anita is getting online harassment and is raped by three other male video game players who despise her opinions. This goes onto show how even as an avatar in the game or a feminist speaking their truth, women are criticized in real life and in the virtual setting.
Another known female who also dealt with hate speech is Ariana Grande. 26-year-old Ariana Grande is a Grammy winner, pop singer and actress who also started her career on Broadway in the production of “13”. She is 5’0 and is always wearing high knee boots and oversize sweaters. Ariana Grande is known for her stellar voice and her high ponytail. Ariana Grande has brown eyes and she is tan-skinned. She has many tattoos all over her body and hands to represent her interests in astrology and music. Being in the public eye, many people tend to misjudge and bring down female artists. She dealt with criticism on the internet and also has been in situtations regarding to sexual harrassment along with racial profiling. In this newspaper article, it talks about Ariana Grande being sexually harassed by a pastor in Aretha Franklin’s funeral. After performing, “Natural Woman”, she stood next to the pastor, and the pastor laid his arm around her shoulder, holding her close. As you can see in the picture on the left, you could see that the pastor was groping the side of her boob. Women at the funeral witnessed the encounter and so did the rest of the world on live television. The whole incident started blowing up on social media platforms, which eventually led the pastor to “apologize” for his actions by saying that it was not his intention and he was being “friendly”. Ariana Grande exercises her First Amendment through expressing her sexuality yet it causes hate speech to occur on social media. After the incident, in particular, people thought that she “wanted” it because of her short dress which is “inappropriate” to wear at a funeral, instead of the bigger problem which is sexual harassment. In the newspaper article, it states, “Instead of focusing on the outward problem of sexual assault, articles were written with headlines such as ‘Ariana Grande’s Mini Dress at Aretha Franklin Funeral’ from Hollywood Life or tweets posted that said ‘Ariana Grande’s ponytail is longer than her dress’ and ‘Ariana Grande needs to fire her stylist, you don’t dress like that at a funeral” (Beg, A). Headlines and tweets similar to these are common for the artist who is constantly getting beaten down by the media through talking about her past relationships, songs written about her ex-boyfriends, outfit choices, and even the color of her skin. Recently, Ariana Grande filmed herself in her natural curly hair and posted the video onto Snapchat. People assumed she was trying to “blackfish” her fans. The term “blackfish” is when a celebrity who does not have any black ethnicity is trying to act and look black. She has been accused before by people saying that her tan is fake. However, Ariana Grande is Italian and if you stand outside in the sun, your skin is most likely bound to become tanner. If you’ve seen her childhood pictures, which are on the internet by the way, her hair is naturally curly. People more specifically men have made their own sexist comments towards the artist as well. For instance, in her “Dangerous Woman” music video, the artist is posing in lingerie to symbolize her sexuality and confidence. Someone tweeted a disrespectful comment about the music video in particular to which Ariana Grande replied:
When will people stop being offended by women showing skin/expressing sexuality? Men take their shirts off/express their sexuality on stage, in videos on instagram, anywhere they want to….all.the.time. The double standard is so boring and exhausting. With all due respect, I think it’s time you get your head out of your ass. Women can love their bodies too!!!
Through expressing her sexuality and the impact it has made onto women in general, many have agreed and also stood by her through saying that it is powerful for a woman to fight for what they believe in. Women in general are criticized by what they wear. In society, women would have to walk on a thread of either being too conservative or too sexy. People make comments about the artist wearing short clothing and heels meanwhile there are Muslim women wearing a Hijab who are still getting catcalled and harassed every day. By wearing layers of clothing women are still getting sexist comments and are body shamed on the internet.
Another woman who has dealt with online abuse is Ashley Judd. 51 year old Ashley Judd is an American actress and a social activist. She is also one of the other 75 women who have accussed Harvey Weinstein of sexual abuse. Throughout her interviews and reports, she has been raped before and the trauma that comes from it impacts her greatly. She wants to be the voice for people who can’t speak for themselves in a traumatic experience like this. However, there are still a group of people out there who send hate speech such as graphic sexual pictures and harmful threats. Hate speech gives haters and mygonists voicing their opinion. Their expression of “right of free speech” contains details of pornographic behavior and a way for egotistical men to judge women into expressing their sexuality. Based on the Ted Talk called, How Online Abuse Of Women Has Spiraled Out Of Control, Ashley Judd points out the details and her own personal experience with online harassment. She exposed usernames and the words of hate that she has seen on a daily basis. According to the Ted Talk, Ashley says, “96% of all postings of sexual images of our young people are girls. Our girls. Our boys are 2 to 3 times more likely---nonconsensually---to share images. I learned a thing or two about revenge porn. It is the nonconsensually sharing of an image used tactically to shame and humilnate a girl or woman that attempts to pornography us” (TEDTalks). The use of revenge porn is highly conducted by men who use that against their significant other or a stranger. More specifically on those who are or have been domestically abused, revenge porn is used as a strategy for dominant men to stay in control. Men would take pictures of women without their consent and expose them either online or spread that specific image to their other male friends. The comments that one girl gets becomes more harmful and will eventually lead to depression.
There are solutions to every problem...well, not all the time, however those who have dealt with online abuse figure out a way to prevent harassment towards young adolescents. There are many non-profit organizations that fight against online abuse. Digging through research, I discovered that Ashley Judd is a part of an organization called the SPEECH Project which is a website that fights online abuse. The SPEECH Project also helps people exercise their First Amendment in a healthy non-harmful way. The Women Media Center allows stories of women who have dealt with online abuse and has given people a chance to be careful online. Using the hashtag #NameItChangeIt, they encourage people to use love speech instead of hate speech. Female celebrities are not only targeted by hate speech but also women in politics. Based on the Women Media Center video, 8 women in politics tell their personal stories of online harassment. For instance, a former state Senator from Texas, Wendy Davis said, “It’s not accidental that in the year of 2017 still 75% of the people who hold office in this country are men. It’s very purposeful” (Soraya). Some may argue however that feminists or those going off about men is because of the way they want to be above men, however that’s not what feminism is about. Feminism is the equality of both sexes either financially, through politics, and many other things. It’s not about being above men but to be equal to men. Another solution that I have come across comes from the ACLU which stands for the American Civil Liberties Union. They have discovered how online harassment causes a major outbreak on how we understand the First Amendment. Yes, people have the ability to voice their own opinion about whatever they want however if that opinion specifically targets someone either by physical or mental abuse should be held accountable. Based on the article, Free Speech and “Cyber-bullying”, it states, “Parents, not the government, are best positioned to police the websites and content that their children access. Efforts to inform parents and their children about what is available online should be encouraged” (Tucker). The solution of cyberbullying and the prevention of online abuse comes from home first. Parents should be able to teach their children to use the internet before anyone else. A parental influence has a strong hold onto a child’s life. The use of education to children at a young age about the usage of the internet could help them develop a sense of expression and freedom. From the Youtube video, What Is Hate Speech? We Asked College Students, “While most respondents to a recent poll, 79% of people agreed that hate speech is immoral and 82% of people said it would be difficult for hate speech to be banned because people can’t agree on what is hateful” (ReasonsTV). Around the ideas of hate speech, people should understand that their words are harmful and could lead to dangerous consequences. Those who use hate speech target populations and minorities to be in control. To learn about digital media literacy, it should be given to not only college students but towards teenagers and children. According to the website, The Intersection of Digital and Media Literacy, it states, “Media literacy generally focuses on teaching youth to be critically engaged consumers of media, while digital literacy is more about enabling youth to participate in digital media in wise, safe and ethical ways” (Media Arts). To focus on the outlet of digital media literacy and how teeangers should be careful they should be taught at school and at home. There are apps out there that don’t have age restrictions which gives children at a higher risk to see inappropriate behavior and actions from others. The chance to teach younger generations at an early age could cause preventions of online abuse in the near future.
Hate Speech comes from people on social media platforms to incite sexism, racial profiling, and cyberbullying yet hide under the First Amendment to cover up their words of hate. In our history, hate groups were already formed like the Ku Klux Klan, Nazis, and white supremiancts who conduct hate through their words. Their influence impacted many lives and in those lives caused many fears among the people. As a society, we need to fix on how we project our opinion and we should learn about the usage of the internet in a safer way. Law enforcement, education, and government officials especially need to incite the importance of digital media literacy and take online harassment seriously. Online abuse can mentally and physically harm someone. On the internet, the harm against women has been extremely taken to a whole other level. With death threats, rape threats, and bomb threats, the internet seriously needs to be overlook and those with authority should do something about it. The First Amendment does give access for everyone a right to Free Speech, however twisting the law by creating a form of Hate Speech leads to fear, harm, and violence. With that being said, the First Amendment needs to be changed or at least more understandable for the general public to understand. People should use their right to Free Speech to voice their opinion but to use the First Amendment to incite violence and to harm someone else is completely stupid. After all, that’s just my opinion.
No comments:
Post a Comment