Tuesday, April 28, 2020

Informative Report



Alyssa Cruz

Professor Matyakubova

ENG201: Composition 2: Disciplinary Investigations Exploring Writing (Section 06)

28 February 2020

Ladies of Justice 

         Due to masculinity in society, women are constantly misunderstood and underestimated by their intellectual ability. Women, in general, were known in society as wives who would stay at home taking care of the kids while their husbands would work. Once women were allowed to work and earn positions that men would have, there exists inequality. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, the first definition of inequality is based on the “condition of superiority or inferiority in relation to something else” (“inequality”). Women struggle with many challenges in their workplace in regards to their superiority. In legal professions, women’s employment rates and percentages are low compared to men; women of color are also much lower than that. Women are undermined in the law field due to a male-dominated field. In the year of 1846, Arabella Mansfield became the first female lawyer in which changed the world today to encourage women to step up to the plate to become leaders in their community. Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan are the only 3 females out of 9 male Supreme Court Justices who sought out justice to influence many individuals to overcome the common obstacles, such as, gender discrimination and social inequality.



Throughout the course of our history, women have been fighting to earn equality and to gain their spot alongside males who are legal professionals. Due to many years of hard work and dedication, women earn legal positions such as lawyers, judges, legal counselors, prosecutors, etc. Yet, women tremendously earn less than men in the law field, “At mid-career, when earnings peak, the top 10 percent of female lawyers earn more than $300,000 a year, while the top 10 percent of male lawyers earn more than $500,000” (Day 2018). As shown on the left, these statistics highlight the economic inequality in which women are underestimated for their ability. With all of these challenges, women lawyers find a way to fight back against the system to achieve justice. There are women in the law field who keep elevating and eventually earn their position to become a Supreme Court Justice.




To have the position of a Supreme Court Justice is an incredible honor for those studying law to become. Supreme Court Justice is a rank in which elevates over judges and lawyers within the legal environment. The process of becoming a Supreme Court Justice is completely honoring especially since it is up to an important person in our country. Based on the website of Supreme Court Justices, “The President nominates someone for a vacancy on the Court and the Senate votes to confirm the nominee, which requires a simple majority” (Supreme). As a nomination coming from the President has such a huge effect on society. Now, college students and students, in general, are inspired to reach their dreams towards endless possibilities. In order to become a Supreme Court Justice, the individual has to study law yet they don’t have to become a judge beforehand.




86 year old, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, fought against gender discrimination and inspired many of her peers to keep moving forward. Throughout her educational career, Ruth Bader Ginsburg held a high academic record and graduated at the top of her class. Once she started a family and her husband unexpectedly got cancer, her challenges arose as Ginsburg was also currently enrolling in Harvard Law School:

At Harvard, Ginsburg tackled the challenges of motherhood and of a male-dominated school where she was one of the nine females in a 500-person class. She faced gender-based discrimination from even the highest authorities there, who chastised her for taking a man’s spot at Harvard Law. (Ruth)

Ginsberg addresses the struggles in the workplace and her personal life with having children. Impressively, Ginsberg is “one of the nine females in a 500-person class” which shows her intellectual strengths. Throughout the years, Ginsburg has achieved many accomplishments yet many people still doubted her ability. During the 1960s, the male-dominated workplace would not hire women to have the same equal opportunity as men. Ginsberg, herself, “tackled the challenges of motherhood” yet dealt with the struggles of being a woman in a male-dominated work setting. Even working for clerks and other male legal professionals, Ginsburg still earned less than men no matter how hard she worked to earn the position. Ginsburg continues to strive in law through engaging in civil procedures, conducting cases, and expanding her legal passion in writing literature about her journey. Fighting for women’s rights, Ginsburg eventually got appointed by President Bill Clinton to become a Supreme Court Justice. Still to this day, Ginsburg is a force to be reckoned with and on the bench, she is known to ask strong avid questions in which challenge others to improve.




Due to the impact on the male-dominated society, women are placed behind the curtain for success. More specifically, in the women who are legal professionals, they constantly have to deal with challenges that consist of gender-discrimination and in similar cases racial discrimination as well. Based on the graph below, women in the legal profession are only “33.3% meanwhile the men are 56.7%” (American). This goes to show how the law field is constantly recognizing the male’s ability instead of women. Although women have those struggles in the legal profession, women of color also have twice the challenges they need to overcome. 65-year-old, Sonia Sotomayor is the first Hispanic and Latin in Supreme Court Justice since 2009. Through watching the television series of Perry Mason, Sotomayor began developing her dreams into becoming a lawyer. She graduated from Princeton College and eventually made her way to Yale Law school. She continues her journey and gains skills in becoming an assistant district attorney. Throughout her career, Sotomayor dealt with many common cases regarding to those who are different in society. One of Sotomayor’s biggest achievement was when she “ruled in favor of a woman with dyslexia who made more accommodations under the Americans with Disabilities Act in order to take the bar exam” (Sheffer). Her decision making not only impacted this case but also her future cases working in a male-dominated field. Sotomayor fought for those who have been mistreated by the legal system. From being oppressed by the system itself, Sotomayor became involved in racial cases that deal with many diverse communities, for instance, Ricci v. DeStefano. Besides legal cases, Sotomayor faced many challenges with criticism from the general law field. Later in the year of 2009, President Barack Obama nominates Sonia Sotomayor to become the first Latina Supreme Court Justice. Through Sotomayor’s experiences written in her memoir, she acknowledges the challenges she has persevered. With the title of the ‘First Latina Supreme Court Justice’, inspires many young women of color to follow their dreams and to keep going to succeed.




The third female Supreme Court Justice is 59-year-old Elena Kagan who has a perception on the use of modern technology and the impact of pop culture. Due to her parents’ profession of being a teacher and an attorney, Kagan is already influenced at an early age to go in the direction of law. For picture day at school, she would dress up as a judge and have a quote of a Supreme Court Justice. Later on, in her career, she graduates with a history degree at Princeton. She was also able to go to college in Oxford, England to earn her master’s degree. By excelling in Harvard Law, she is moving up the stairs step-by-step to achieve many accomplishments, for instance, Kagan became the dean of Harvard. With her accomplishments, Barack Obama nominated Elena Kagan and “the first female solicitor general” (Elena). Having that specific title, adds towards the diversity among the justices. This also includes a sense of perspective among the male-dominated position. Based on the website about Elena Kagan, it states, “Kagan added a diverse viewpoint as the youngest sitting justice and the only sitting justice with no prior judicial experience” (Elena). With the perspective of her colleagues, it is extremely impressive at a young age that Elena Kagan is “the youngest sitting justice”. On the other hand, Elena Kagan dealt with challenges in the workplace. For instance, her lack of experience of judicial proceedings would be the reason why she is “the only sitting justice with no prior judicial experience” and this would also be why her male colleagues would underestimate her. However, with further encounters, she gradually learns quickly and puts in the hard work to make smart decisions.




The three females on the Supreme Court Justice, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan are the ones who sought out justice to influence many individuals to overcome the common obstacles, such as, gender discrimination and social inequality. Ruth Bader Ginsburg overcame work inequality by proving to her peers on her intellectual ability. Sonia Sotomayor fought against racial discrimination and became the first Hispanic Supreme Court Justice. With no prior experience in the judicial system, Elena Kagan preserved in her struggles and put in the dedication to succeed. Women in law have many challenges by their male-dominated field, however, women will always work hard to change the narrative. Witnessing the change in the law department, inspires many young girls out there that they could do it as well. Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor, and Elena Kagan are the real Ladies of Justice in which shaped the world and the lives of young girls.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Final Examination: Final Course Reflection

       From my previous experience in ENG101 to ENG201, I'm proud to say I improved a lot on research, presentation skills, public speak...